Projects

Tumblr

kMunic8

Home

Things Journo Grads Should Do

Earlier this week Mark S. Luckie from 10,000 Words gave advice to graduating journalism students and suggested 30 things they could do this summer.

The list started like this:

  1. Start a blog and post at least twice a week
  2. If you already have a blog, write a post that gets retweeted 20 times
  3. Shoot 100 amazing photos and post them on Flickr
  4. Friend at least 50 journalists on Twitter who in turn follow you back
  5. Become a part of a crowdsourcing project

and ran up to number 30.

I liked his suggestions — a few are ones I’ve told my journalism students to pursue — and shared his post with one of the journalism listservs I’m on.

“You can quibble with the details,” I wrote, “but I generally think this is spot on and will pass it along to my students.”

The first response was positive:

That is spot on and some points we should probably all learn! Thanks for the to-do list!

The next response, not so much.

Before I get into it though I think I can safely say that our mainstream brethren aren’t quite the shining stars we might hope them to be. Off the top of my head I can think of today’s Washington Post pay to play snafu (Charles Kaiser sums up its repercussions nicely); NPR’s banning the word “torture” from its coverage of Bush era interrogations; and Fox’s Glenn Beck continued journey to looneyville when he apparently agreed with a guest that “the only chance we have as a country right now is” for bin Laden to “detonate a major weapon” in the US.

Really?

So, yes, I agree with Luckie that our graduating journalists have some independent training to do. Hopefully they’ll apply it to new, independent news operations that start to show what real journalism can look like.

Slate’s Jack Schafer is right when he writes that digital disruption will improve journalism. We — and our graduates — just need to practice and take advantage of what this technology is providing.

Without further ado, here’s the back and forth.

Wow. Is this what journalism has sunk to? “Start a blog and post at least twice a week.” Is the author taking it on faith that all these new journalism grads just automatically have something to say that is so pressing and relevant they have to broadcast their thoughts twice a week?

Perhaps they do, perhaps they don’t. I know a 2008 grad that got his current “mainstream” gig because he did have something to say, and said it well. Without the blog, the hiring editor never would have come across him.

However, think of a blog simply as a platform. It doesn’t necessarily have to include opinion or “thoughts” as you imply above. I’ve told my students in the past, if you graduate and want to cover City Hall but haven’t been hired to do so, start a blog and start reporting. Get your ass down to City Hall and break news.

You don’t have to wait until Newsday comes calling. Better, do it with a partner and report as fiercely as you can so you make a name for yourself. You’ll eventually get noticed.

That’s what i think of when someone says, start a blog. The blog, as a public platform, lets us pursue what truly interests us if we haven’t been fortunate enough to be hired for the beat we really want. Use it.

And that they’re all such skilled photographers that every one of them can post “100 amazing photos” that other people besides their friends will actually care about?

If you’re not skilled enough to begin with the only way you’re going to get there is to practice. So i tweak the “take a 100 photographs directive” and say, take thousands, but you can only have 100 up on Flickr/your site at any one time. That way, you learn to edit yourself. You learn to develop and eye, you learn a variety of skills, including editorial judgment, that will come in handy.

Or is he/she assuming that it’s OK to produce content for the sake of producing content?

Well, is it not ok? Athletes practice. So too artists and musicians. Should journalists not lift a finger and perfect their writing, shooting, editing, etc. unless they have an actual, honest to goodness signed, sealed and delivered assignment from an editorial desk? I’d rather have that budding journalist do it publicly where he or she can get actual feedback from those who see, hear or read their work.

How else do you propose people get better?

Nowhere in this post is there any mention of actually, say, reporting. Why not instruct new grads to spend time in underrepresented communities and find the stories that mainstream media is missing?

Well, I agree with you there and hopefully my tweaking shows that reporting is part of the process in the recommendations. And yes, go take those pictures and write pieces that aren’t covered in the mainstream media.

We don’t need thousands of new journalists who know how to use Photoshop and Twitter. Any child can do that. We need journalists who actually know how to report and write, and who pay attention.

We do need journalists who know how to report and write, and who pay attention. And we need them to be able to produce that content in and for a medium that most people are now using to get their news. That’s the web. Photoshopping required. Which, apologies to any of my former students on this list, is not something any child can do.

Final thought. The author who posted the original list recommends following 50 journalists on Twitter. I disagree.

Leave the echo chamber and follow 50 people in the beat and subject matter you want to report in and on. Immerse yourselves in the links and knowledge they’re sharing. It will do you well.


Now, she did conclude her rant with, “We need journalists who actually know how to report and write, and who pay attention.”

And this, of course, is absolutely true.

Semantics Matter. On the Social Web, Stop Calling Us Consumers.

If Twitter is chattered conversation you need to treat it as such. If you approached a social gathering like a party and said, how am I going to use this situation, and worse, articulated it and acted like it, you’d come off as abrasive and crude.

Codes and Tubes

I’ll be teaching at Columbia this fall and am considering what the Web site will be for the course. Drupal, Elgg, BuddyPress, Pligg? They’re all good. Not quite sure what I’ll choose but here are some of the ideas we’ll be talking about.

The Brother Gibbs Political Talk Show

A Bee Gees political talk show? I would’ve tuned into that.

Yellow

What made Coldplay great was Yellow. Since then? Yawn.

Playing with Toys - Issuu

Started playing with Issuu to see what it can and could do. Tested it out with photos from my Subway series.

Copyright, Excerpting and Fair Use

Publishers raise concerns about bloggers excerpting their content. They miss the point.

The Effects of File Sharing, EU Style

Lost in the US debate over the cost and benefits of file sharing is a very important player, ourselves.

Writing from my iPhone

Downloaded the WordPress iPhone app and am giving it a whirl.\\n\\nTrue, WP has a function where you can email in posts but, equally true, I …

Tags:

Saving the News: A Headache That Won’t Go Away

The endless chatter about saving journalism is a growing headache that won’t go away. Day after day there’s another article, talk, email thread, tweet or …

Plumbers, Foreign Correspondents and the New York Times

Lost in the snickering that Pajamas Media is sending Joe “the Plumber” Wurzelbacher to Gaza as its “War Correspondent,” is the fact that PJTV.com is …

We Can Work it Out, or Not

A day after Norwegian public radio network NRK announced the release of every Beatle’s song as part of a podcast, lawyers say, Not so fast.

Geek You Can Believe In

The Information Technology and Innovation Foundation issues a report that large-scale investment in US technology infrastructure could lead to a million new jobs.

Introducing the MacBook Wheel

Apple introduces revolutionary new laptop with no keyboard.

Barack and Britney Tweeting in a Tree

Hackers use Twitter’s internal admin tools to hijack accounts and post all sorts of nasties.

Google, Ideas and You

Google Product Ideas lets you play product designer by submitting your most fanciful desires for future mobile device development for consideration by their engineers. Wish …

Frogtalk - the Michael & Sasha Edition

Frogtalk 02. Michael and Sasha hanging in a tree.

Frogtalk

Introducing frogs, that talk to each other. Otherwise known as Frogtalk.

Firefox Up, IE Down: Welcome Back, Browser Wars

Firefox cracks 20% market share for the first time, Google drops IE 6 support and IE — in all its nasty flavors — drops below …

JPG Magazine Folds

Innovative JPG Magazine announces they’ll fold January 5, 2009. Not the most optimistic way to start a new year.

Booty: A Google Word for Pirate Treasure

A 39-year-old Las Angeles musician claims he found upwards of $3 billion in buried treasure off the Texas coast with the help of Google Maps.

Diplomacy, One Tweet At a Time

Israel takes to the Intertubes to answer questions about what’s what in the Gaza Strip.

A Healthcare Marshall Plan for Millions, Not Billions

A $50 billion Marshall Plan to save healthcare? Not. How about lopping off a couple zeroes and doing it for $70 million? The answer’s in …

You Want Porn with that Broadband?

For the past seven months, the Federal Communications Commission has kicked around the idea of auctioning off a piece of the wireless broadband spectrum in …

RIAA to Stop Lawsuits and Go After Internet Access Instead

After filing some 35,000 lawsuits against Americans in an effort to combat music piracy, the RIIA will drop its legal assault and move on with …

Warner Music to YouTube: Remove Our Music Now

Warner Music demands that YouTube pull down all videos that contain its music, claiming revenues generated are negligible.

Complete Archives

Background: About